Cash For My Miles vs Sell My Miles (2026)
A numbers-first comparison for anyone deciding where to sell airline miles or credit-card points.
Side by side
| Cash For My Miles | Sell My Miles | |
|---|---|---|
| Trustpilot rating (June 2026) | 4.9 ★ — 1,300+ reviews | 4.0 ★ — 223 reviews |
| In business since | 2004 — 47,000+ clients served | Their site cites 10+ years |
| Programs purchased | 50+ airline, hotel & credit-card programs | Most frequent-flyer miles + credit-card points (per their site) |
| Payment | PayPal-first for qualifying sellers — paid before we redeem; in as little as 15 minutes or the next business day | Varies by transaction (per their reviews) |
| Quote process | 60-second online quote + WhatsApp quotes in chat | Quote by request form |
| Support | Phone, WhatsApp (516) 806-5659, email | Web / email |
The bottom line
Both companies buy a wide range of miles and points. The measurable gap is reputation depth: as of June 2026 Cash For My Miles holds a 4.9 Trustpilot rating across 1,300+ reviews, versus 4.0 across 223 for SellMyMiles.com — roughly six times the review base and a meaningfully higher score, on top of a track record going back to 2004. We also quote in 60 seconds online or right inside WhatsApp, and pay PayPal-first for qualifying sellers. Compare both quotes — the numbers are the argument.
Disclosure & sources: this page is published by Cash For My Miles. Trustpilot figures were pulled in June 2026 and change daily — always check the live profiles: Cash For My Miles · The Miles Market · Sell My Miles · MilesBuyer · Mileage Spot. Competitor feature claims come from their own public websites. Nothing here is financial advice.